I could spent close to $300 for the ATI replacement/upgrade or $169 for this add-on (not a video card).
I really don't want to stick another graphics card up in the closet just to get the features I could get much cheaper.
true, just showing you possibly for a new box.. I would suggest the AIW X1900 or x1800 PCI-x if you were building a new box...
Do you have Windows MCE? make sure you have if you are going to be using the NVIDIA DualTV MCE tuner card.