How is his interpertation less valid then yours?
And, exactly, where was it stated the the nat guard troops will be unable to carry ammunition and unable to detain an illegal?
From the President himself and his spokepeople.
From the president stating there would not militarize the border.
From the fact they've stated the Guard will be there to observe and essentially listed the duties the Minutemen already perform.
As far as the "Observations", the observations concerned what people who want a secure border desired. I think as a person who demanded action on this, I am qualified to state that "observation" is not what we desired.
We desired the borders fenced/walled from left to right, and right to left. Not pieces of structure. We demanded that talk of amnesty/guest worker be stalled until they secured the border. Not passed in conjunction with their lame carrots ensuring its unlikely our borders will be secured anymore than they were fom the last legislation two decades ago. We wanted strict eomployer sanctions enforced, we've nothing to suggest that'll occur. If they were serious they'd have done it by now with the laws on the book. So, no, it is WRONG to state we got what we wanted.