I agree with you on almost all of the hosts. Gibson can be very funny. He's overbearing too, but he takes himself with good humour and is pretty knowledgable. But I can't deal with O'Reilly ... I listened to him a couple of times on the radio and he's just a bad radio host. The TV show has some good segments, but by 8 p.m. EDT, on 3 out of 5 days at the minimum I have something else I want to watch.
O'R is ok on most of the issues, as far as I can tell, but he is just such a shameless flirt (on both radio and tv) that it makes his act almost a comedy to me. You would think after his sexual harassment flap, he would be more careful.
No, he has his nose firmly up any 1/2-way pretty arse thatwinds up on his shows.