It's unfair to compare presidents in non-war time to presidents in time of war. I loved Reagan. IMO George W. Bush is a giant among presidents and will be memorialized as such by history. I'm so darn grateful he's our POTUS. Reagan and Bush both had their own high wire acts, and both masterful at the art of politics.
More to Bush, I cringe to consider how a man of lesser conviction, moral compass and steely resolve could traverse these volatile times and minefields, and I believe Reagan would back Bush 100% (if Nancy didn't interject).
Has it ever occurred to you that you just wish Bush looked like this? 
"It's unfair to compare presidents in non-war time to presidents in time of war."
Reagan was a War time president - he won the Cold War (and a few hot wars too); but, why let any of that get in the way of your worship of the "W".