[Hildy]

So what's your point? Would you have been happy if they cut her head off? And if you say no...you're lying. And that's sickening.

[goldstategop]

It would have been poetic justice. I keep thinking about the lefty peacenik who was murdered and dumped in Baghdad. Hating America will all his heart didn't save him from his fate. Caroll was only spared because of the intervention of the Treason Lobby here who have not lifted a finger for other Americans held hostage. That and the terrorists holding her finally realized she could promote their aims far better alive than dead. No doubt she'll tell us we need to understand and negotiate with these people. That's the nature of Caroll and her fellow Communist ilk - scorpions waiting to sting you to death because its in their nature to do our country harm.

(Denny Crane: "I Don't Want To Socialize With A Pinko Liberal Democrat Commie. Say What You Like About Republicans. We Stick To Our Convictions. Even When We Know We're Dead Wrong.")

[mkjessup]

GoldstateGOP said:
Jill Caroll is STILL an Islamist, terror-supporting Tokyo Rose.

Then YOU said:
So what's your point? Would you have been happy if they cut her head off? And if you say no...you're lying. And that's sickening.

Perhaps you could explain how you get 'lying and sickening' out of a statement of truth that "Jill Caroll is STILL an Islamist, terror-supporting Tokyo Rose."?

Jihad-Jillie was never in any danger of getting the Nick Berg treatment because as has been amply pointed out, she was (and IS) ONE OF THEM!

Talk about premature articulation!

[rlmorel]

I think the point GoldstateGOP is making is that even though she may have said the things in her interview under duress, if you throw out the parts about her not being mistreated, then what she said does not differ substantially from what she said before she was kidnapped, as a free person.

I didn't hear him imply that they should have cut her head off. She is lucky they didn't...but he did imply that she is closer ideologically to any of her captors than she is to any of her fellow US Citizens.

Personally, I am glad she was safely released. I hold out hope that she may understand the real nature of the people she supported, but...I am not holding my breath.

If there is one thing that human beings do very well, it is to rationalize and justify.

[John D]

Why would they cut off her head if she was in on the so called kidnapping? She wanted to help her muslim buddies get some money, but that did not work. Now she wants to write a book.