Says who?
"Defective only if it was possible to create beings that would never choose Hell yet be fit for Heaven."
Are you saying that it would be impossible for God to do that ?
I suspect so; can you argue the contrary?
"Since they were never in a position to make the correct "choice"
Says who?"
Soory, I might have made a wrong assumption that you were a Christian. If so, the "word" was not available ( according to traditional theory), so a correct choice could not have been made.
"Are you saying that it would be impossible for God to do that ?
I suspect so; can you argue the contrary?"
You appear to have a very different concept of God then an all-powerfull being, normally God is not given any limitations.