Yes, I did say that. That it was in accordance with your logic.
But tossing souls into eternal hell is not particularly compassionate act to do to your creation either, so maybe it's part of the whole " in the image of " thing.
I don't know. I'll leave it to you to speak for God and judge his actions. I'll stick to responding to what posters on this thread have to say for themselves.
I didn't make the rules, go argue with God.
"Thou shalt not commit murder." Wasn't that one of God's rules?
God is making the promise of heaven, you propose to force a path which may wind up in an eternity of hell.
Isn't another of his rules "Thou shalt not bear false witness?" Not being a student of the Bible I'm not sure where it says that if you save someone's life you are then responsible for their soul's ultimate destination. Apparently you're more familiar with the passages that reference that.
""Thou shalt not commit murder." Wasn't that one of God's rules?"
Yep, but I didn't see any " Thou shalt become an enforcer of whatever you think my rules mean against all others." in the list.