Posted on 03/24/2006 8:28:46 AM PST by Blogger
Right now there's absolutely no evidence of what her motive was and there are no news reports giving any solid facts. Hence, aside from the pleasures of mental masturbation, there's no reason at all to speculate on what caused her to do it.
It is noteworthy that she didn't hurt the children, and she took them with her. Time will tell what happened and why.
If he was harming one of the kids, I think I would have taken them to a physician/hospital?
He had it coming
He had it coming
He only had himself to blame
If you'd have been there
If you'd have seen it
I betcha you would have done the same!
I always wondered if it wasn't some kind of hint.
I know I'll get flamed for this, but post-partum depression is a real disease that can be overlooked or the woman can feel ashamed to ask for help. If she does get help, doctors hand out anti-depressants like candy. AD drugs often cause changes in personality that lead to violent behavior. I've seen it happen personally (from afar) several times. I know of a father who killed his daughters, a mother who killed her children and a woman who walked into the lake and drowned herself all on anti-depressants. We are too trusting of doctors and drugs, and afraid to speak up if we are having strange side effects. How do you tell the side effects from the depression?
Mary Winkler will pay for this crime if she committed it, and she should, but if depression and/or drug treatment percipitated her behavior, I now have one more reason to tell my doctor lock me away rather than give me anti-depressants if I ever need them.
Never fear, Micky Sherman is on Fox trashing both of them now.
....after looking at the family picture and seeing how unresponsive (sad) the middle girl and the baby were, plus the artificial smile on the oldest daughter, I suspected the same thing.
I was an abused child myself.
Ugh. Greta's next case.
Fox is reporting the wife has agreed to return to TN to face the charges. Not fighting extradition. Waiting for PC to begin.
So was I, SweetCaroline, but we must be careful not to see everything as a nail, just because we were hammered. (messing with that metaphor, I guess)
But, family photos tell way more than most realize.
hummm....there is more to this story.....someone waiting in the wings perhaps...
By the way, the husband's parents are asking for custody of the 3 children.
The biggest concern I have with this case, is that we need to find out why a precious Mother of three, the pillar of the community, would feel the need to blow her husband away..
There WAS a reason...
BTW, I am thinking that she shot him in the BACK, because when she confronted him with the gun, he started to walk out. So she shot him then.
sw
Another article said she had rented a condo on the beach, but hadn't stayed there?
For an example of a minister that has engaged in habitual domestic abuse Go here
There is a lot of reading, but it does mention how Phelps knocked his wife down the stairs, breaking her arm. It also mentions how Phelps beat his children with a mattock handle (I consider that Asault Wth a Deadly Weapon). There is radiographic evidence of the injuries suffered by the boys, which supports the allegation that Phelps beat them.
http://crime.about.com/od/female_offenders/p/deathrowwomen3.htm
All of her husbands either beat her, committed adultry or molested her children too right?
Fox said press conference was at 10:30. I wonder if they thought it was 10:30 Eastern or Central?
No flames from me -- I'm pretty sure there will be something "extenuating" in the case.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.