[Fred Nerks]

If you don't appreciate Prophet of Doom, I'm sure you will enjoy Edward, Canon Sell. He was a Fellow of the University of Madrass, wrote several books on the subject of islam. Other than that, I cannot be of any further help to you, there's more than one POV - if you are unable to include any western thought or literature in your search for truth, then you're stuck on stupid I guess. You are not debating, but trying to stuff your opinions down my throat.

And I am NOT interested in parsing the koran and hadith word for word.

Sorry, I'm an Aussie, we're stubborn. Those tactics doesn't work.

[RS]

"You are not debating, but trying to stuff your opinions down my throat."

My opinion was on your choice of a source... a proven poor choice, since I have pointed out more then one bogus quote from that same source.

Not controvertible, not inaccurate, not a point of view difference, simply made up "facts".


Now as far as Sell goes, his books might have some bearing if our discussion involved whether the Koran was truly a revealed book of God - As I have said before, I don't care, so if it makes you happy to call Mohammod a dirty rotten pig farmer, have at it.

Not a particularly good move if your object is to kill the bad guys and calm the rest so I might question your motives in doing so, but I'm not going to argue the point.

[Fair Go]

Aussies don't like being pushed around, period.