Posted on 03/08/2006 1:24:59 PM PST by alan alda
It would be interesting to draw up a comparison of how many movies have been made about the Nazi crimes against humanity as compared to those of the Commies.
Considering that Commies killed somewhere between 3 and 10 times as many people, I would guess there have been at least 6 times as many movies about the Commie crimes against humanity.
Sobran is a jackass.
What does that have to do with this article?
Ed asner said he wants to play Stalin. He says he was misunderstood.
You do have a very good point there
That's the classic hollyweird line when they step on their tongue with both feet
That is a complex question that has fascinated me. Here are some of my notions about it:
1. First, the obvious: Jews, because of their intelligence, their intellectual ~energy~, and their undertandable passion around this issue have been able to push the case of genocide that most concerns them ahead of other crimes which had more victims.
2. The Holocaust was different in that it was an attempt at specifically ~racial~ genocide, unlike the crimes of Stalin which were political rather than racial.
3. Because there is a long history of anti-Semitism, the Holocaust seems more significant. It can appear as the culminaiton of a lot of history.
4. The Holocaust was carried out with modern technology and factory efficiency by an "enlightened" Western "democracy," (at least somewhat democratic before the Nazis got control).
5. Jews, whose intellectual power seems now almost undiminished even by this horrific episode, have generally had a relatively collectivist political sensibility and have not been eager to indict the USSR as the moral equivalent of Nazism.
And he’s the commentator who warned that "History is replete with the lesson that a country in which the Jews get the upper hand is in danger. Such was the experience of Europe during Jewish-led Communist revolutions in Russia, Hungary, Romania and Germany."
"Where is the corresponding statement of Jewish leaders repudiating and repenting the Jewish role in a cause whose crimes dwarf those of Hitler? Did major Jewish spokesmen or organizations condemn Communism as it devoured tens of millions of Christians?... Even today, how many Jews condemn Franklin Roosevelt for his fondness for Stalin, as they would condemn him if he had shown the slightest partiality toward Hitler?"
Sobran apparently views Nazi criminality not as in a class by itself, but rather as one of many crimes committed by governments against those it sees as opponents. He correctly, IMHO, points out that our society spends probably 100 times more energy denouncing the crimes committd by the Nazis than those committed by the Commies.
I disagree with much of what he says, but the statements above about how Commies and those who support them get a pass are pretty accurate.
IOW, which is worse, Ideology A or Ideology B?
Ideology A killed somewhere around 12-15M people. Ideology B killed somewhere upwards of 100M people.
Doesn't take a higher mathematician to figure that one out.
Sobran, Buchanan and Paul Craig Roberts are the Troika of Paleoconstipated Moonbattitude.
If they make such a film, they're going to need to assemble a team of the world's best digital sound specialists to edit out the rustling sound made by his back hair.
I haven't read Sobran regularly for a long time but I never saw him write anything like this guy is suggesting.
The reason the Nazi Holocaust gets more attention is because it was Genocide in the Industrial Age...an attempt to wipe out a group of people concentrated into a very short period of time. Dictatorships, Communist and otherwise, that kill their own citizens have existed since time immemorial and will continue to exist until Utopia (forever).
Is that isn the medical dictionary?
I think there is a very simple reason for the difference.
Most of those who write and make movies in America agree with the claimed goals of Communism: equality, freedom, etc.
Very darn few agree with the Master Race ideology of the Nazis.
So the Commies, from their point of view, are just overzealous good guys, while the Nazis are bad guys by definition, as their very goals are evil.
It will be someday. Scientists are still studying the phenomenon.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.