Posted on 03/03/2006 4:08:20 PM PST by SandRat
God Bless the Holbert Brothers. May God keep this from happening to them that happened to the Sullivan Brothers. My Thoughts and Prayers are INCOMING for all of them!
Damn. These guys have to salute each other at home?
/johnny
I think rank goes out the window.I served with 3 siblings at the same time.I outranked them all,but my oldest sister was still boss!
You are thinking of the 5 Sullivan Brothers from WWII.
"You are thinking of the 5 Sullivan Brothers from WWII."
Yes, they are the exact Brothers that I am thinking of. Hopefully unlike the Sullivans they all won't have to be exactly the same spot all the time. Being on the USS Juneau in the middle of the ocean, they were all together.
I'm sorry about that response SandRat. I was reading crosseyed and not seeing you wer replying to mdittmar.
IS OK Jose'
I could not help but think of you.
A story you might like to know about.
Found this, you might find it enlightening, I did.
Is it true that . . . Congress passed the "Sullivan Act" to prohibit family members from serving together on the same ship or in the same unit in the military?
The answer is no. There is no such act or law. However, after the Sullivan brothers were killed, there were several bills introduced in Congress that related to family members serving in a military unit together. None of these bills were enacted into law. However, there are military policies and directives to discourage immediate family members from serving together.
The facts: The five Sullivan brothers of Waterloo, Iowa, enlisted in the Navy on the same day, January 3, 1942. The brothers were assigned to the U.S.S. Juneau, which was torpedoed and sank on November 13, 1942, killing all but 10 crew members. Although an existing Navy regulation forbade the assignment of the brothers to the same ship, their request to serve together was granted. The existing regulation was issued in July 1942, and was certainly influenced by the loss of the U.S.S. Arizona during Pearl Harbor, with three brothers among the casualties.
Yes your right , I knew that too. What I believe is true is that the Navy itself will prevent this from happening in their service. I do believe that these Holbert Brothers had to do alot of paperwork or whatever it took even inside the Army to keep themselves together because no one wants this to happen again. That doesn't mean it won't though. I'm a ham radio operator and last summer I made a contact with a special event staion in Iowa that was Honoring the Sullivan Brothers. It was one of the most special contacts that I ever made and they sent me a lot of info about the Sullivans. Thanks for coming back to me SAMS and this Airman sends his BEST to YOU and YOURS. Take good care of your Soldier and Marine. I know there must be some inter-service rivalry at your house because my son is a Sailor and I get it all the time about how the Navy is outdoing the Air Force. It's a lot of fun though.
Thanks for the ping!
Although proposed after the death of the five Sullivan Brothers, no "Sullivan Act" was ever enacted by Congress related to family members serving together. Similarly, no President has ever issued any executive order forbidding assignment of family members to the same ship/unit.
Thanks for that picture. I recieved it from the special event staion I contacted last summer. These Brothers like the Holberts will never be forgotten by me.
"Take good care of your Soldier and Marine. I know there must be some inter-service rivalry at your house because my son is a Sailor and I get it all the time about how the Navy is outdoing the Air Force. It's a lot of fun though."
Oh that's not even the half of it! My Dad was Navy, I was Army and my two brothers were Marines! And to add to the fun, we have cops and fireman in the family who like to play the "who's better/tougher/in more danger game" LOL!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.