Why would the freedom of information act cover anything that is still classified?
There is an exception to the FOIA for classified documents. But that does not permit the Government to ignore the request-- they have to respond, on an item-by-item basis, and either release the document or assert whichever exceptions they think are applicable.
This judge did not order the Government to turn over any documents-- he ordered them to respond to the request. This is a valid order and will probably be upheld if it is appealed. I assume the Government will respond by asserting the national security exception.
Ya got me!
Some of these judges believe they are above the law - meaning they can rule whatever they want and it's the law. They are wrong on that count. If that were the case - there would be no law. Idiots!