[jveritas]

I understand your point and you have a good argument there however I still believe that for this particular case he voted the way he did because he just did not have enough time to review it since he has been on the US Supreme Court for only few hours. Anyway I do apologize for calling your earlier argument "dumb". :)

[jveritas]

Some people on this thread were already implying that we had another Souter on our hands with Justice Alito and that is absolutely wrong. I hope that you agree with the vast majority of us that Alito is a conservative judge.