Excellent point. I'll have to take some time to read the proposal again.
I'm glad you like it! When you figure it out, maybe you can explain it to me. I'd also like to know why if it will work 6 years from now to get 11 million illegals to leave when they revert from guests to illegals, why we couldn't just start doing it today.
My guess is that there is no intent that these guests will ever be made to leave and even if there is an intent our juevoless politicians won't be able to muster the political will to get it done. That is why I call it a shamnesty. There will just be an endless string of visa extensions and eventually, after maybe a dozen or so years we will find ourselves with an enormous group of second class citizens. It will be clear they live here permanently and are never leaving but they will be treated inferior to others because they will be denied things like Social Security (and they will eventually get old). It will be very tough politically to deny them these benefits when they have paid into the system and contributed to our economy. It will also be very tough to continue to deny them the vote. Taxation without representation in anathema to the American way.
I'd prefer to leave them illegal and let the anger of the American public continue to rise until eventually we start throwing some politicians out of office. At that point, I think we will get a real solution that does not involve amnesty.
And it does not need to involve mass roundups. That is a strawdog argument from the OBL that we have a black and white choice between amnesty and gestapo style roundups. It is a false choice. I have outlined a better plan in my post #277. Let the illegals self-deport.