[Ben Ficklin]

I do recall the discussion we had that you have linked to(#160) which is a different topic than what you posted above.

If you will take the time to go back and read my response in both instances, the response is the same.

Making compliance harder, more detrimental, more stupid is not the answer. It has to be made easier.

Do you want your guest worker reg to be one page long or 300 pages long? Do you want your IRS reg to be one page long or 300 pages long.

Now I know that you think that Tancredo has the bill right, but have you've ever wondered why Senators Vitter or Coburn didn't introduce Tanc's bill into the Senate. After all, they are former menbers of Tanc's immigration caucus.

[moehoward]

Perhaps a "different" provision, but the same topic, your misrepresentation of Tancredo's plan.

" Do you want your guest worker reg to be one page long or 300 pages long? "

I don't want one at all. But if we have one, it should be Tancredos. As far as page count, it's not how many, it's what is contained in those pages that matters.

But if fewer pages = better plan in your book, looky here.

John McCain/Teddy Kennedy Secure America and Orderly Immigration Act, 85 pages.

John Cornyn/Jon Kyl, the Comprehensive Enforcement and Immigration Reform Act, also 85 pages.

Tom Tancredo, REAL GUEST Act, 49 pages.