What is your goal? An America where a hundred languages are spoken driving a wedge between every faction? An America that isn't quite "chocolate" but rather a nice shade of brown?
Do you have a heritage you wish to see survive or are you all for supplanting two hundred years of heritage with another?
Why should we give in?
The heritage I have is a country that has always welcomed newcomers. And then assimilated them into the "American" culture. What's the problem with keeping that heritage?
My main point is that the option of deporting 10 million people is not an option. It will never happen politically, not because the left has the ability to stop it, but because not even the right wants it enough to fight for it.
So if we're not going to deport all those people, what is the next best thing? I think some combination of carrot (a guest worker program of some kind) and stick (border enforcement and employer/employee sanctions) is the answer. The goal should be to make it easier for a foreign worker to work legally, than illegally. They *are* going to work, so let's bring them into the system somehow.
For those that stay, we should insist they learn English, and study US history in school to complete the assimilation into the "American" culture.
Where am I going wrong?