[Cboldt]

when he has disagreed with his circuit, hasn't the USSC agreed with him more times than not?

I don't know on that one, for sure, have heard the assertion made but never looked it up. But the charge being made is that Alito is HIMSELF inconsistent.

[retrokitten]

But the charge being made is that Alito is HIMSELF inconsistent.

You mean like "I voted for it before I voted against it"? That kind of inconsistant?