I read from about 2 dozen and in none of them does (tradition is not relationship) Replacement Theology hold any water. That's not just a damaged bucket holding not water, it's not even a bucket (Replacement Theology) according to any Word study I've ever been a part of.
Bravo!
It is really pretty simple.
God's chosen people are now Christians, as Christians make up His people and are the only ones who can be saved. Do you as a Christian believe that Jews who do not come to Christ will be saved? Do you really believe that a "true Chosen person" can't make it to Heaven?
I don't deny that Jews will have the opportunity to be a part of a kingdom on Earth after the Rapture, as per Revelation.