Maybe.
They do give him problems, but if Miami had played the rest of the year like they played that night on defense, the BCS would be in serious trouble becuase it would have 3 undefeated teams.
At the time though, he had only started something like 8 or 9 games as a QB. Mostly by his own doing (since he got himself suspended for the 2004 season), but most QBs not named Matt Leinart are going to struggle inside of their first 10 games as a QB. It's just a fact of life.
Miami should have beaten FSU if they could have gotten anything going on offense that night although it's hard to do that when your QB gets sacked 9 times and gets whacked a bunch more times. They also lost to a G Tech team with a fast defense and a hell of a wide receiver and they simply didn't show up for the game of post game fight where they got their asses kicked in both.
With respect top Vick, this might have been his first year as the starter but don't forget that he played quite a bit in 2003.