How about neither? The House passed a good bill, let's go with that and talk about any possible guest worker plans after the border's secured. Otherwise it'll turn into 1986 all over again, just another bait and switch where it becomes all amnesty and no enforcement.
Frankly, I have not read the house bill, but it sounds better. However, you know the Senate..rarely do they let something pass the House without putting their handprints all over it...lol. Here is the Cornyn/Kyl bill:
http://www.cornyn.senate.gov/immigration/
Anyone that says that Cornyn is a Rhino or the worst conservative senator is simply not well informed or worse..a troll.