I'm sorry, but I really believe in my faith. I'd rather remain single for life than turn my back on it. Considering I would be unwilling for my kids to be raised as anything BUT Catholic, that pretty much means, I'd have to marry a Catholic.
So again, it's not that simple. ;-)
...Or who is willing to become Catholic ;~D Keep your options open, maybe his family just got lost and wound up at the wrong church.