[sharkhawk]

I wonder what the screams would be like here if the valedictorian was a wiccan who asked everyone to come up to the stage to join the coven, or if it was a mooslim who asked everyone to get on their knees and pray to the moon rock. I agree it is not a first amendment violation, but the graduation was not the time or place to make this call.

[muawiyah]

Hmmmm. What would be the "screams"?

How about "the Constitution requires that the state stay out of the issue".

[SoothingDave]

I wonder what the screams would be like here if the valedictorian was a wiccan who asked everyone to come up to the stage to join the coven, or if it was a mooslim who asked everyone to get on their knees and pray to the moon rock. I agree it is not a first amendment violation, but the graduation was not the time or place to make this call.

Exactly. Yet some one here will tell us with a straight face that they wouldn't mind.

SD