[AndrewC]

Problem is, none of this had in the least relevance, since the OSC admitted it had no jurisdiction

I guess that makes it OK.

[Right Wing Professor]

The Smithsonian declined to cooperate with the investigation once it was determined OSC lacked jurisdiction. It was therefore an entirely one-sided opinion by McVay about a case which he shouldn't have investigated, and to adjudicate which he was unqualified. Its merits should be evaluated accordingly.