It's a very strage turnabout, yes. And they're not so much America first as modern social-liberal values first.
Ford and Lindbergh saw themselves the great defenders of the modal American values of that era, 1870 thru 1930, a starched-collar cookbook morality. Yoffe and the Reform congregations equally. They see themselves as the great defenders of the modal American values of this last modern era, 1940 thru 2000, a tye-tied I'm-Okay-You're-Okay libertineocrity.