Personal email? Did this student send emails to the faculty members personal accounts? If this guys email address has .edu as an extension, I don't believe that would be a personal email address, would it?
And even if it was his HotMail account (which I highly doubt), there seems to be a double standard (what a shock) considering the Duquesne University student who was threatened with expulsion over a comment he wrote on his FACE profile.
I sent him an insulting song. He has an aol.com email address.