In that context, it is indeed automatically disrespectful. "Tu" is used when you're addressing a social inferior, such as a child (even a stranger) or a servant, or to a friend. You say "vous" to anyone who out-ranks you. That's why using "vous" is used when talking to strangers, the way we use "sir."
But I think "tu" is considered correct usage when talking to criminals.
lmao at u guys. U folks crack me up.