Nope he will absolutely not. Alito is more clearly pro gun and anti Roe than Luttig. Alito will drive Specter nuts.
I agree. While I love Luttig, I would rather have Alito. I am bothered that Luttig helped throw out Virginia's partial birth abortion ban which was clearly allowable under Roe.
Do we know what Luttig's position is on Roe? Is it that he truly has less of an animus towards it than Alito, or that he so far hasn't indicated one way or the other?
If that is true than I hope Alito is the pick.