That is not for us to judge. If he was worshipping the one true God (and we have to assume since he was a Rabbi that he was), then God could reach him with the truth of the Messiah. If your church kicked him out, you would be in danger of becoming a "stumbling block" to the Rabbi's conversion to the true Messiah (ie. Messanic Jews).
Just my opinion....
If he was worshipping the one true God (and we have to assume since he was a Rabbi that he was), then God could reach him with the truth of the Messiah. If your church kicked him out, you would be in danger of becoming a "stumbling block" to the Rabbi's conversion to the true Messiah (ie. Messanic Jews). Just my opinion.... That is a legitimate opinion. The issue is quite subjective and as such the greater good is weighed by the shepherd of the flock. Considerations of one soul that is persistently and or defiantly in error against those of the souls that may be led astray and or corrupted by exposure to the persistence and or defiance... The shephard made his call which God alone can judge...