According vox_PL logic everyone who live in America and speak english are americans:).
Your smiley in the end of the phrase is totally inappropriate. Though you used the statement sarcastically, it is exactly true!==
Yes of cause so all millions of illegals in America are "trully americans" according to you:)). I beleive that the majority of FR participants will very much disagree with you.
BTW how about millions of muslims which lived in France and Britain? Are they "trully frenchmen" or "englishmen" too?
Not withstanding thier muslim religion and very different race?
If above is true then of cause Mototov and Stalin who was born by georgian and jewish father and mother are "russains" to you. But it is fortunate that it is only to you.
But who you are yourself ethnically. DO you newzealender ethnically since you live in New Zealand. But I presume you was born not as new zealander. SO despite of your mother and father which has nothing to do with New Zealand you are new zealander? Funny:))).
Same way jb6 here according to you is german? Since he lived in Germany and speaks german language?
How about arabs in Israel? AFAIK the third of population of Israel is arabs. Who are they then?
According to you they are jewish:))). They speak ivrit and they live in Israel. So all your conditions are here and they are jews:). Funny indeed:))).
I think israelites on this forum will vehemently disagree with you:))))). They don't recognise arabs in Israel as jewish despite that arabs live there and speaks thier language. I beleive that Israel arabs will disagree to be jewish too.
SO do I.
I don't recognise Molotov, Sverdlov, Stalin, Beria and so on as ethnic russians. And no logical and resonable people do.
Except of those who like it according thier political suit. It is convinient indeed to call any international commi scum as "russians". But they are "russians" same way as arabs in Israel are jewish.
Vanjusha, I've already asked your most politely to cut the crap, but that stuff is obviously too abundant in your brain system, and it overwhelms you. Please receive my condolences then...
You either don't understand the fundamental difference between the illegal over-stayer and American citizen, or don't recognize main principles of belonging to the great American nation. But methinks that to serve your political agenda you're just making yourself a bigger buffoon than you really are .
Is Condi a, say, Angolan, or American?
Is Rudy Juliani American or Italian?
Is Collin Powell American or Jamaican?
Exactly in the same way all those you "don't recognize" for Russians are, and Soviets they're too.