I pretty much have removed myself from these threads, as I am quite convinced all sides are firmly entrenched in their positions; arguing over this is simply a waste of time.
I will say this, however. Peggy Noonan's reference to the President's past drinking problem is one of the tackiest things I have seen a columnist do, especially one who purports to be a Republican and a Christian. She should be ashamed of herself.
W often talks about his conversion experience. In his conversion he found the grace to make needed changes in his life. Noonan is suggesting that Bush could find the grace to regroup and bolster his presidency. I would avoid ascribing an evil motive to her column.