Prove that statement. You mean "up to the job" like Beyer, Souter, Kennedy, Ginzburg and O'Conner? That is the whole problem here. NICE you have opinions, they are NOT facts. Sorry she is NOT who you want but NONE of you have made even the beginning of the case that she "isn't up to the job". Amazing how supposed "Conservatives" now want an Ivy League school degree and a rabid following among the Legal guild as a qualification for the SC. YOU did hear both Scalia and Pickering DO NOT agree with this opinion of Miers didn't you?
You misunderstand me. By "up to the job" I don't mean that she isn't smart enough. I mean that I don't know if she can be counted on to be a real, conservative, strict constructionist judge of the kind needed to put a stop to our drift into liberal judicial tyranny.
I certainly don't think that Souter is up to the job. As a constitutional judge he's a moron, whatever his IQ may be.