I'm in favor of some kind of middle ground....a school that is truly owned & run "lock,stock, & barrel" by a community and also a requirement that children must attend a certain amount of schooling.
I agree. And I think the amount of schooling should depend on what they want to do.
In the 19th century kids spent fewer hours and days in school and learned more in 8 years than kids learn now in 13 years. With computer classes, kids could easily outpace the current crop of high school graduates in 4-5 years.
In other words, by age 10 they would have a superior education to what 18 year olds get now. Then they would be free to pursue higher education or specific job training until they were 16 or so and could pursue employment.
I realize I'm dreaming big.