YES! If we want enduring conservative decisions, decisions that last and last and that we can all respect, then they must be well and forcefully reasoned. It is not the vote that counts, but the reasoning of the opion that carries the weight and affects how the law will operate for centuries hence. If this woman were capable of the heavy lifting we would have seen some evidence of the bulging intellectual muscles sometime somewhere. You don't have to have played for a conference champion team to become a great football player. But man, you are not going to get recruited if the coach has never seen you play football.
Perfect. And absolutely irrefutable.