Posted on 10/05/2005 4:46:00 PM PDT by tuffydoodle
School Library Book Raises Porn Questions
POSTED: 3:14 pm CDT October 5, 2005 UPDATED: 4:58 pm CDT October 5, 2005
GRANBURY, Texas -- A book on a Granbury middle school shelf recently ignited a controversy because of what at least one grandparent believes to be pornographic content.
Carol Sanders said she was shocked to find out her 13- and 10-year granddaughters read "Detour for Emmy." The book tells the story of a 15-year-old girl who becomes pregnant.
Sanders said the descriptions of sexual relationships were graphic and crossed the line into pornography.
"It's something that I don't like reading myself. It's just too sexual. It goes into great details of having sex," she said.
Sanders began the process of filing a complaint with the Granbury School District. The district's book committee will decide if the book should be removed from the school library. Copyright 2005
Oh, so this is the enlightenment?
???
I need more details from you.
You're right, it has to come from the parents though. Sure, a lot of parents don't talk to their kids... that's a big problem. It's not the schools job. Do you know they have had parents children taken away for neglect because the school felt they were keeping them from sex-ed?
No lie.
I too, being originally from the South know of what you speak (stepfathers raping and molesting daughters, mothers doing nothing... sending them away to have their babies with their aunts, sending the child back), a lot of times they have been told (like you said, but not before), they are the lowest of the low... and there goes the rest of their life, either nymphos or psychologically damaged for a large part of their lives.
You can teach your children about sex without exposing them to disturbing literature. That way they can be informed but still innocent.
When my kids were 7 and 9 I took them to the library and showed them the same book I read when I was their age. It describes reproduction and birth in a matter of fact way.
And afterwards they were still normal kids. They are 16 and 14 now and good kids. There is no sign that the book did them any harm, or me either.
You can teach your children about sex without exposing them to disturbing literature. That way they can be informed but still innocent.
When my kids were 7 and 9 I took them to the library and showed them the same book I read when I was their age. It describes reproduction and birth in a matter of fact way.
And afterwards they were still normal kids. They are 16 and 14 now and good kids. There is no sign that the book did them any harm, or me either.
Erm,
I'd like to think that some of us manage to make a decent enough life for ourselves ;)
'A Tree Grows in Brooklyn' has no literary standing.
How would you define graphic? Foul Language? Fornication? Scatology? Incest? Cross dresssing? Because that would eliminate much Shakespeare and most Medieval Literature not to mention Faulkner and Hemmingway.
Who decided that?
And aren't there books with "literary standing" that don't involve deviant sex? (and aren't mind numbingly boring)
Where do you draw the line regarding reading material for 16 year old kids? Is anything "off limits"?
I've yet to see a literary scholar defend it as a sigificant piece of American writing. I'm sure there are people who think Stephen King should taught. That doesn't make his work anything more then Penny Dreadfuls. 'One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest' is one of the key novels of the Beat Movement and certainly isn't boring.
I think at 16 when you're just talking about text they should be able to handle the entire Literary Canon. We read 'The Sound and the Fury' in High school, an undeniable American classic and quite explicit in terms of subject matter. And please note I'm talking about 15 and up teenagers not 9 or 10 year olds.
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest is one of my all time favorite books but it is absolutely not appropriate reading material for 16 year old kids. I'm not really concerned with what a literary scholar thinks when it comes to exposing my kids to adult material.
Literature is a matter of opinion. It's not based on facts, like math.
The kids in the article are 10 & 13.
My 10 year only learned much about sex this past year because I told it to him.
My almost 9 year old daughters only know one bad word A**.
My kids all go to public school, and they are all still very innocent.
It's not that difficult to remove them from all of that.
We use the parental controls on the TV.
We limit what movies they see.
We limit what songs they listen to.
We monitor what books they read.
We only have playdates with kids whose parents are also very restrictive.
The kids are 10 & 13. Reread the article.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.