Pick out the ones that were responsible for most of what we know as science. You're presuming to know that if the ToE was in existence at that time that these men would have undoubtably believed in it. How arrogant to assume that you know what's in someone else's minds and speak for them.
I dont assume they would be evolutionists, but I think its laughable to offer them up as doubters when the theory you are contesting didnt really exist at the time (and incidently is outside their notable fields).
Presumably you would offer Hippocrates beliefs as evidence that the elements are earth, air, fire and water.
http://www.answersingenesis.org/Home/Area/bios/default.asp