There are plenty of former Evolutionists with advanced degrees that have become Creationists or at least believers in a Deity because of the contradictions of Evolution. Here are some: http://www.creationists.org/outstanding.html , but there are many others.
If there are any evolutionists who are even interested in understanding the creationist viewpoint; there is a good book out called The Fingerprint of God by Hugh Ross. It would give you some insight into creationist thinking.
Did or did not Darwin denounce evolution on his deathbed?