Good post, FSE, that's what my son has told me. The commanders know how to pick the ones who they want to retain after they have taken their punishment.
Of course, there is a supply and demand element (personnel wise) to all of this. Fifteen to 20 years ago there was a 0 tolerance policy in the Army.
Absolutely correct. Right now, from my perspective as a Platoon Leader, every Soldier is critical. True, I have over 40 of 'em, but if we automatically boot them without regard to situation, then that number could be whittled away quickly. Take into account the latest recruiting difficulties and the new Brigades that are standing up all over the country, the likelihood that I would get a replacement is slim.
Back in the Cold War days, as I understand it, there was no shortage of personnel, and Soldiers were easily replaced. Not quite so anymore, sadly.