Are you nuts? Shoot him later - extract information from him now, by any means necessary.
Of course. I meant to say AFTER he's been drained of all information via Industrial Strength Cattle Prods to tender areas.
Extract information first, then....
this reminds me of what my father said if he was a judge and guys like the Shoe Bomber came into his court. After the testimony, my father would signal the court guard to come over, he would wisper in their ear "Give him the #1" and accused would be escorted from the courtroom never to be heard from or seen again.
This guy needs the #1 treatment.
Nah, shoot his toes off, one by one, and see how he sings. If that doesn't work, kneecap him.
If that fails, strap him to a dead pig...then kill him.
Paging Jack Bauer? Sounds good to me!