Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: AWest
You may ask questions after you have answered mine. I asked them 1st. I will answer your question once YOU answer mine. Trying to defect the discussion by asking questions of the questioner instead of answering the questions put to you is ANOTHER common Logical fallacy used by the Hysteric Left. Answer the questions.


How come you IGNORE the fact that Govt Blanco did NOT ask for any Federal Assistance until Wed Aug 31st according to HER, or Until Thur Sept 1st according to FEMA. ALL the Declaration of Emergency does is release Federal Disaster AID money to the State. It does NOT, as the Hysteric Leftist try to lie about it all over the web these days, Give the Feds control of the Local Govt's authority and responsibilities. The Govt of the STATE is still in charge of HOW the resources, particularly the NATIONAL GUARD, are used. FEMA advises the locals, they do not DIRECT the locals.

Please explain to me why the Sun Sept 4 WASHINTON POST (A pillar of DNC propaganda) reported that the President had ASKED to take over control, and Gov Blanco of Louisiana said, and is still saying, NO?

Why TODAY, if the 3rd Responder Feds are to blame and not the 1st Responders (City of NO) and 2ND Responders (State of Louisiana) is the MAYOR of New Orleans issuing order for evacuees to be removed by force if necessary? I thought the Feds were in charge of all this.

How is "This Administration" to blame for what the Gov and the Mayor are IN CHARGE OF?

A couple more questions to answer.

Why despite billions in Fed Homeland Security money pumped into the State of Louisiana and the City of NO to equip 1st Responders are both the City of NO Police and Fire Departments after 9-11 are both so woefully under equipped and staffed and in such lousy morale even BEFORE this disaster?

Why, despite the fact that FEMA tells states and localities that it can take anywhere from 72-96 hours for the Feds to get significant resources to them were both the City and State completely unable to meet even their most basic responsibilities?

For example, despite calling on the City to use City owned buses to evacuate those unable to move themselves out of the City as part of the Disaster Plan posted on the City of NO's OWN website, are all those buses still sitting in the City of NO's lot?

Despite actually planning to respond to EXACTLT this disaster, why did the City of NO and the State of Louisiana not meet even one of THEIR requirements under the plan?
192 posted on 09/07/2005 1:38:19 PM PDT by MNJohnnie ( Blaco say Wed Aug 31st, FEMA says Thur Sept 1st.. Who is lying?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 190 | View Replies ]


To: MNJohnnie

Wow, you just don't get it do you. Yes, Blanco should have requested help from the Gov't before she did, did I ever defend Blanco? Does that mean that the Gov't is absolved of all responsibility until it receives a formal request? Give me a break. If Giuliani hadn't requested assistance on September 11th, did that mean that the Bush administration didn't have to do anything but wait for people to die en masse? This is a ridiculous argument. Now, as for the WAPO article, don't you think Louisiana could have used that assistance WHILE people were dying and in desperate need of help. Why is the Mayor of N.O. issuing orders for evacuees to be removed by force? Well, primarily because the area is a disease infested cess pool. If the Feds were going about this, it wouldn't be incumbent upon local authorities. So, just when does the administration become accountable? Now, having answered all of your questions that never begged to be answered, care to answer any of MY questions?


193 posted on 09/07/2005 1:54:36 PM PDT by AWest
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 192 | View Replies ]

To: MNJohnnie

Now that I've answered your questions:
You mention billions of dollars being pumped into New Orleans to equip first responders, care to back that up with any proof?

I've read of many requests for mere MILLIONS to reinforce the levees which were breached years before this disaster occured, which was never received. So, how about posting some FACTS with regards to that.

Also, if an emergency declaration was declared on the 26th (according to the White House) and FEMA takes anywhere from 72 to 96 hours (it takes that long to provide essential support to a disaster? Did it take that long on 9/11?), why is it that nothing was seen on a Federal level until the 2nd?

As for the buses, you're damn right they should have been put to use. That could have been another few hundred people rescued or put out of harms way, but nothing in comparison with what a fully coordinated Federal effort could have been capable of. Are you suggesting that thousands couldn't have been saved if a coordinated Federal effort had been put in place in time? Helicopters used wherever possible to lift people out of that insanity? Helicopters used to drop food and water when it was necessary (no, I don't mean yesterday). A military presence in place to keep a semblance of order. Lemme guess, it was too dangerous or difficult for them to get in? The most well trained and efficient military in the world and somehow they weren't able to tread where the intrepid reporters of CNN were? Are you planning on answering these questions or just posing more of your own?


195 posted on 09/07/2005 2:04:43 PM PDT by AWest
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 192 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson