My pick would be Krauthammer, Barone, and Sammon.
As for looks, I'd keep Nina Easton, but only if you add Megyn Kendall and Martha McCallan. Who cares what their opinions are!
As a side note, now would be a good time for Fox to go after Bob Novak.
It would be a good time for Nokak to get an eyelid lift! Too many late deadlines.
Novak and Cal Thomas. Pundit Emeriti !
Martha's voice drive me nuts..like chalk oin a blackboard..Megyn is really hot, and smart..and methinks a rising star....you know what would be the greatest job..being the guy who gets to scout out all the potential new Fox news babes..