Let's rate the FOX "All STARS"..the best and worst of the panel..who would YOU "vote off the show??"

one man's opinion.......

[piperpilot]

Two should be replaced with Kiran Chetry and Juliet Huddy

Hey, what happened to Juliet Huddy? She seems to have been replaced on F&F Weekend with Gretchen Carlson.

[Apercu]

Not that I would ascribe certain types of conduct in order to keeping one's job (oh hell, I just did), but I think you know the answer to "contacts".

[MeanWestTexan]

I think its temporary. Or at least I hope so.

[BigTime]

Ping for later reading.

[llevrok]

Dream Team? Krauthammer, Noonan, Miller.

I love Peggy's mind and most of all her writing. But on TV she gets very syrupy

Dream Team:

Snow as Moderator, The 'hammer doing editorials, Brit (politics), Laura (judicial), Juan (comic relief);Mara (utility infielder and designated cougher)

[Gaffer]

.... Ceci Connelly....getting lots more air time of late..WHY???......

The answer to that is OBVIOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Who's she 'doing'?

[ozzymandus]

Juan is the stupidest, but the 2 lib women are close behind.

[piperpilot]

Krauthammer is far and away the show's genius.

I know you all will think I'm crazy, but I think Charles Krauthammer is HOT!!!! I love that hang dog look. I also think Benjamin Netanyahu is HOT, but that's another discussion.

[goodolemr]

Charles Krauthammer is the only one who's ever got me thinking.

[Mike Bates]

Two should be replaced with Kiran Chetry and Juliet Huddy.

And for panelist No. 3:

[Proud_texan]

"Juan, the whipping boy for Brit."

Most excellent!

Parenthetically if you caught Juan on the old Crossfire show it's amazing to see how he's toned down his commie side since coming to Fox. Now he's only comic, on Crossfire he could say some really outrageous things.

[oldbrowser]

Krauthammer is probably the only one I would keep.

Krauthammer is the class of the panel, the rest of them are just props.

[toddlintown]

Fred Barnes...too full of himself. Constantly interrupts.

Mort Kondrake..feel sorry for him. More confused than ever since the passing of his wife.

Mara Liasson..she coughs a lot, but not lately. During the Christmas holidays, it got sort of hard to follow the segment with her hacking all the time. Take a lesson from Peter Jennings and put the Virginia Slims in the garbage.

Juan Williams....token moron.

Charles Krauthammer..medical and legal degree and confined in a wheel chair since his early 20s. An inspiring individual...and yes, he should have his own show.

Jeff Birnbaum...that annoying grammer school classmate who jumped around a lot when he had to pee.

Bill Sammon...When he's on with Krauthammer, they're unstoppable.

Ceci Connelly....getting lots more air time of late..WHY??? Showing more cleavage, that's why.

Nina Easton..by far the best looking female panelist, but seems to try too hard.

[Gimme]

"Jeff Birnbaum...that annoying grammer school classmate who jumped around a lot when he had to pee. "

LOL :)

[pollyannaish]

I love the fox all stars. I don't care for Ceci at all, but not sure why.

Mara, Fred and Jeff are ok, but a little bit too predictable. I like them all, I just don't learn all that much. I prefer Fred's schtick on Beltway Boys with Mort. But I would miss him if he was gone. I prefer Jeff on the 'Splainer Man segment on Saturday mornings with Brian Wilson.

Definitely look forward to seeing Mort, Charles, Bill and Nina. Wish they had a stronger female conservative-leaning voice.

Hope that Juan never, ever gets voted off the island because it's so entertaining to watch all the others jump on him for reciting dem talking points. That is half the fun for me and I would miss him if he was gone. Plus, I've seen him on O'Reilly and other shows where he was very sensible, so I think he's just playing a role. He is very personable.

I wish Michael Barone was still on. He is amazing, but I guess I'll just have to be satisfied with his newly launched blog and occasional guest appearances. I enjoy the fill in anchors, Jim Angle ('specially when he giggles) and Brian Wilson. I miss Tony. Brit is my hero. 'nuff said.

[pollyannaish]

I would definitely keep Paul.

[llevrok]

Nice...um...eyes.

[mware]

I would definitely keep Paul.

Paul Gigot and Bill Sammon float my boat.

[pollyannaish]

Yeah!

[pollyannaish]

Hmmm...of a type I see. ; )