[HiTech RedNeck]

he did no work on this case other than in a mock court exercise and with regard to the PROCEEDURAL aspect of appellate law.

I think his brain got ahead of his common sense. Even if it was doing something as mundane as mimicking Scalia.

[msnimje]

I think his brain got ahead of his common sense. Even if it was doing something as mundane as mimicking Scalia

Why? What if he actually thought the lawyers could present the best possible case before the Supreme Court and the Justices would decide it correctly? Judge Roberts lamented the fact that the Rehnquist Court is NOT CONSERVATIVE.