Holy Toledo! You gotta SHOP, man! Get an agent to do it for you, and he'll do it gladly.
I've always been "sensitive" to health care insurance, because I have never had or been involved in any sort of company plan - it's always been strictly 'out of pocket'.
We're both 58, and would be paying around 9000 bucks had we not downgraded to a higher deductible plan earlier this year. Somebody's hosing you, bigtime from what I read.