Turley is liberal. Durbin is liberal *and* a liar. I believe Turley: Durbin told Turley Roberts said this. But Durbin now publicly denies it.
As for Roberts, who cares? Even if he may have flubbed and said this about recusal, it was an off-the-cuff remark made during what is supposed to be an entirely off-the-record "courtesy call." It is hardly an indication that he somehow would recuse himself in any significant proportion of cases due to his religious views.
You're right. Turley's always been truthful -- he's a liberal, but an honest one...