[Lancelot Jones]

"A nuke attack on the US by ANY muslim entity, is an act of war upon the US by Islam as a whole."

There are anywhere from two to six million American Muslims, are they the enemy as well?

What about Turkey?

There are 150 million Muslims in India...is India then an enemy?

Beauseant!

[dirtboy]

There are anywhere from two to six million American Muslims, are they the enemy as well?

If they look the other way as potential attackers plot in their midst, well, then, yes, they are a problem.

Are they the enemy? Depends upon your definition of such. But, then again, isn't that what this debate is all about? Who is the enemy in this asymetrical war where we aren't quite sure who is friend or foe?

[dalereed]

"There are anywhere from two to six million American Muslims, are they the enemy as well?

What about Turkey?

There are 150 million Muslims in India...is India then an enemy?"

You bet, kill them all!

It's either them or us and they have stated so.

[Publius6961]

There are 150 million Muslims in India...is India then an enemy?

I was just wondering about that very point earlier today. Perhaps you can help further.

How many Hindus are there in Pakistan?

[SauronOfMordor]

There are anywhere from two to six million American Muslims, are they the enemy as well?

Consider the context of the original scenario, which postulated 20 or so nukes going off in the biggest American cities. Tens of millions dead, and millions more dying from radiation poisoning. Every person in the US would have had close friends and relatives among the dead.

Because of Islam

You seriously think there would not be a response that would make Rwanda look like a Chucky Cheese birthday party? There would be Muslims hanging from every light pole from Boston to LA, and there would not be a damn thing the government or anybody else could do to stop it