No, but it is pretty clear you are bought-in to the ILEC weltanschauung.
In my view there is blame to go around: The CLECs have been incompetent opportunists, and the ILECs have been greedy and corrupt - for example, looking the other way as their unioninzed employees sabotage non-union ILECs' gear. But the ILECs are the biggest problem and biggest bribers of politicians.
When CLECs stop basing their business plans on the subsidy provided by below-cost forced leasing of the ILEC network, I'll take them seriously. Non-facilities-based competition is a feel-good mirage Reed Hundt concocted for Al Gore's benefit.