As evidenced by FR polls, there will be some diagreement amongst conservatives no matter who Bush nominates. But........... if Bush nominates anybody the dems find acceptable, I will be disapointed greatly. So, my OK goes to anybody the dems would fight over.
There are at least 5 excellent choices who would have voted the right way on Kelo and roasted a bone over the corpse of the New Deal. Just because I have my favorites is no excuse for Bush to go for the bottom of the barrel.