Posted on 06/24/2005 9:28:51 PM PDT by neverdem
I live in the West and South Dakota is no where near here.
Speaking as a history teacher and a published author (I even have an agent) -- Well, yes, the language of the old west was colorful. But in a tv series, IMHO, when every other word is the "F" word, that's not colorful, it's an example of weak writing. Profane language and it's proper use is an art. Ask any marine D.I. Those guys can curse for fifteen minutes and not repeat themselves once. But for a writer, such language should be used as a surgeon's scalpel for maximum effect. When it's used as a bludgeon, as it is in Deadwood I find it get's old and boring real fast. Historically I don't think the show is very accurate, either. Too much intrigue.
How many blacks are on the show? I can't remember. But one in seven cowboys was black. There were very few gunfights in the real west, because most everybody carried a gun as has been posted here. Same reason each town had one sheriff and a couple of deputies. When the good guys had their hands full the whole town loaded rifles and made their desires known.
How many blacks are on the show? I can't remember. But one in seven cowboys was black
I would very much like to learn about this and the stat. Do you have an url, pls?
However, on another score.. In re weaving a fabric of utter brilliance using profanity? You think Marines got the corner on that Market? Meet some soldiers.. (grin)
I totally agree. Sure there was colorful language and lawlessness, but the show is way over the top. I enjoy the show, but cringe a lot also. I have been to Deadwoob several times, but when I think of it, I more often think casinos than anything. Of course, the town was all but dead before the casinos.
I spent 14 years as an officer of army infantry. I know. But yes the corps DI's still have the corner on profanity as an art form.
Not to nag; but do you have that url or book/article about the black cowboys of the west being ratio'd at approx 1:6?
I got this from Ask.com: By 1877 and the end of Reconstruction ... 94% of blacks lived in the South, did not own land, few had gone west to homestead ... 50% of cowboys were black (poor pay) ...... and it is a Georgetown University class....synopsis. Of course as economic advantages rose or fell, the percentage of all occupations shift by demographics.
Not only had I heard this; but it is logical and fits perfectly in with all other available data.
Buffalo soldiers, for one. Here's a link:
I hadn't quite thought of black cowboys fully -- but you are right: These were amazing men.
"Over 180,000 African-Americans served in the Union Army during the Civil War. Of these, more than 33,000 died. After the war, the future of African-Americans in the U.S. Army was in doubt. In July1866, however, Congress passed legislation establishing two cavalry and four infantry regiments (later consolidated to two) whose enlisted composition was to be made up of African-Americans.
Cowboys. On horseback. Buffalo Soldiers.
If I may be so immodest, of course I'm right. I was social studies teacher of the year at my high school in 2001. Teaching is one of the very few things I do very well. But you did the right thing. Something I drill into my students daily. Don't take anything anybody says as being absolutely true. Check it yourself. Find the other side. Especially: Look for a person's AGENDA when you are told something!
My classes always seem to fill first. I have had parents with children who had me in the past call the school to demand the younger sibling be put in my classes or moved from another class into mine. That's a responsibility I take seriously and so I do my homework before I open my mouth. Seventeen years and counting.
A gifted teacher creates a perfect and wholesome hunger in any student. Thank you for teaching; and teaching so well.
~Blushes Furiously, scuffs toe in the dust~ Aw shucks ma'am. Thanks.
:) Thanks, again, for challenging me to make the connections! I had data.. I hadn't quite connected it in the way you suggested.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.