You guys should have started catching stray New Yorkers and holding them in deep animal pits as hostages until the City relented and paid you a fair price. Short of that I really don't know how to get a New Yorker's attention.
It's always been tough up there.
Part of it was a bunch of enviro weenies also, there's ridiculous 'fire safety' laws also. A lot of the water still comes from the Catskills.