Me, too. It's nauseating to have to agree with Chuck Schumer...but there is NO redeeming value of this game. Let people order it secretly and have it delivered to their house in plain brown wrappers, like they get their hardcore porn.
This is nothing more or less than violence pornography.
I am for the most part a libertarian, and I live like one for the most part (not proud, just honest.) But I completely agree with you on this one. Treat it just like pornography. That's pretty much what it is. Interactive fantasy violence. You hit the perfect balance in a free society. It shouldn't be banned, but decent people should shun it.